Using AI for Your Manager Interviews…Not Always the Best Idea

We recently came across an article on Yahoo.com that spoke to using AI for your manager interviews titled “An Aggravating New Barrier is Making it Harder Than Ever to Land a Job.” The article highlights how many job candidates are frustrated with AI-driven interviews, which are discouraging them from pursuing potential positions. I want to discuss the interviewing process, specifically for hiring individuals for self-storage positions. I believe it is essential not to use AI in the interview process, and I have key reasons for this.

AI Misses the Nuances During an Interview

First, AI cannot perceive the nuances of human interaction. During an interview, a human interviewer can pick up on subtle cues in a candidate’s body language, tone, and expressions that reveal their true feelings or intentions. This is crucial when evaluating a candidate’s suitability for a self-storage manager position.

Candidates Need to be a Good Fit for the Storage Location

Second, finding the right person for the correct location is vital in our industry, and AI cannot replicate the personal touch required in hiring decisions. Personal interactions during interviews help foster a better understanding of a candidate’s fit within the company culture and the specific needs of a location.

Personal Connections are Essential

Lastly, hiring decisions greatly benefit from human interaction. Effective management in self-storage relies on these personal connections, which AI cannot provide. Thus, relying on AI in this process could undermine the effectiveness of our hiring practices.

How AI Can Get it Wrong

Let’s discuss what AI can get wrong in the hiring process and what it fails to understand. One of the significant limitations of AI is its inability to assess a person’s emotional intelligence or the interpersonal skills necessary for self-storage management. These nuances are aspects that AI cannot readily identify, which can result in oversights where qualified candidates may be overlooked due to algorithm limitations.

I also believe in recognizing the potential of younger candidates, even if they may seem inexperienced. When I observe them in action, I often consider their potential, especially when paired with an experienced team member. I must understand the dynamics of my current staff, including their personalities and aspirations, to ensure a good team fit. For example, if one team member is quite dominant, I would prefer to hire someone who is more easy-going to balance the team rather than having two dominant personalities in one store, which could create challenges. Cultivating a complementary team environment is vital for success.

When it comes to hiring and fostering team dynamics, it’s essential to create synergy within the team. To achieve this, focus on personal interactions and assess how well each candidate aligns with your existing managers, as this is crucial.

AI Won’t Get Your Candidate Excited About the Job

The personal interview is significant because it helps build rapport between you and the candidate. When trying to attract top talent, you need to present a compelling offer that sounds appealing and attractive. It’s essential to engage with candidates in a way that makes them eager to join your team, rather than relying solely on automation or technology.

Interviewing face-to-face in the hiring process allows for better rapport-building with candidates, ensuring they possess the skills you’re seeking. It’s essential to have genuine interactions, as AI can sometimes come off as robotic and may not fully grasp the nuances of potential job performance.

In my experience, I’ve often been able to tell quickly whether a candidate would be a good fit for the role. I believe AI would struggle with this aspect of evaluation.

AI Has Its Place in Self-Storage…Just Not in the Job Interview

I believe it’s essential to focus on hiring individuals who will fit nicely in a specific location. Hiring should always be a personal process rather than an automated one. I understand this can take time, but if we don’t get this aspect right from the beginning, it becomes much harder to let someone go later on. If you rely on AI for hiring and encounter issues, it may quickly become apparent that it lacks understanding, especially if instructions weren’t clear. At some point, you will need to interact with the candidate before they start working in the store.

Ultimately, the human touch is crucial for determining a candidate’s fit within a company’s culture. Sometimes, that human element is something that AI cannot grasp. My concern with relying on AI for hiring stems from the fact that a significant portion of a manager’s role involves having the right personality. I prioritize hiring individuals who are not only positive and friendly but also compatible with the team of each specific store, qualities that AI cannot grasp.